← Chapter 3
Mental Health Nursing · Chapter 3

Ethics Bench: When Two Rights Collide

A dilemma is not a fight between right and wrong — that is just a temptation. A dilemma is two things that are both right, where honouring one means failing the other. For each case, name the two principles pulling against each other, then choose the next nursing move. The resolution is never heroic; it is a conversation, a choice offered, an escalation, a documented rationale.
Case 1 of 6
Step 1 · Name the two principles in tension
Pick exactly two principles. If a third looks tempting, ask which one is actually losing if you do the obvious thing.

The scale

— — NAME BOTH SIDES
A principle lights up when you have correctly named it in a case.

What just happened

Start with case one.

Read the case, then choose the two principles that are genuinely pulling in opposite directions. Both of them are right. That is what makes it a dilemma rather than a mistake.

0
Tensions named
0
Moves chosen
0
Cases done

The process, not the instinct

  1. Clarify the conflict. Say both goods out loud, to yourself and to the team. Unnamed tension turns into irritation with the person.
  2. Test capacity for this decision. Not the diagnosis, not the admission status — this decision, at this hour.
  3. Find the least restrictive path. A different route, a different agent, four hours’ delay, a family member present, a real choice.
  4. Escalate rather than deciding alone. Provider, charge nurse, patient advocate, ethics committee. An ethics consultation is an ordinary clinical resource.
  5. Document the reasoning, not just the outcome. What you weighed is the part that protects the person — and you.
Moral distress is knowing the right action and being blocked from taking it by staffing, hierarchy or policy. It accumulates, and it is a leading reason nurses leave psychiatric settings. Naming it in debrief and pushing the constraint back up the chain is professional practice, not complaining.